BULL ON A THIN ROOF

Tennessee Williams Cat on a Hot Tin Roof deals with the dangers of mendacity—how lies and omissions controvert and destroy. Big Daddys dying of cancer but doesnt know it, while everybody else except Big Mama knows and agitated “first born” Gooper and his snoopy, forever preggers wife Mae plot to use the secret to commit “avarice and greed.” Meanwhile, baby brother Brick is boozing in despair over his best buddy Skipper having killed himself after he not only admitted to sleeping with Maggie but that it was Brick whom he really wanted to bed. As punishment, Brick engages in “nightly refusals” to pump frustrated, clawing Maggie. The whole shebang of high-strung lunacy was certified as Pulitzer Prize drama and did smashing box office on Broadway. Though the movie directed by Richard Brooks was also a huge hit, Williams was quite prescient when he said that no one would buy into the nonsense that Paul Newmans Brick preferred the bottle to Elizabeth Taylors scrumptious Maggie. We didnt, and to this day nobody can figure out exactly what Bricks problem is; well need the Hubble telescope to find anything of Skippers real predilections in the movie. (And theyre not all that clear in the plays text, either.) Just as ludicrous, no one utters the word “cancer” and 1958 movie censors demanded that the salty language be excised, including the word “crap”—changed to “bull.” Appropriate, considering the scenario. Doubling as adapter, Brooks slices away line after heavy, superfluous line the plays characters get drearily bogged down by, and this is enormously beneficial to the movie actors—it energizes them, with more amusement and uplift than Williams originally intended. (He wrote a downer third act which theatre director Elia Kazan convinced him to change; youll know why when viewing the Natalie Wood-Robert Wagner and Jessica Lange-Tommy Lee Jones versions.) Recreating their Broadway roles, Burl Ives as Big Daddy and Madeleine Sherwoods Sister Woman are smashingly entertaining demons of the southern Williams kind; Judith Anderson as Big Mama and Jack Carson as Gooper are warty gargoyles, validating Big Daddys none too silent disdain for them. As pinnacles of 50s icons, Newman and Taylor are just about at their ripest, so of course it is a hoot that Newman can watch Liz straighten her seams or walk around in a super-sexy slip and then feign a lack of arousal. The absurdity saves the picture, making viewers giggle suspiciously at Williams intentions. He objected to casting Taylor because shes the antithesis of his vision of Maggie. Though he denied that Bricks a closet case, who could blame Brick for feeling guilty in thinking that Skipper might be a better roll in the hay than Barbara Bel Geddes? Directors of subsequent revivals never dared to duplicate that mistake. Taylor created the mold Elizabeth Ashley, Wood, Lange, Kathleen Turner and Ashley Judd would accommodate—Maggie as a sultry feline, not a frumpy sap who satisfies a playwrights penchant for cunning propaganda. No music attribution, though IMDb lists Charles Wolcott as uncredited composer of original score. Not sure if thats true, but some of the score has been lifted from André Previns music for  the 1949 Tension.

BACK  NEXT

    

ralphbenner@nowreviewing.com  

Text COPYRIGHT © 2000 RALPH BENNER  All Rights Reserved.Text COPYRIGHT © 1997 RALPH BENNER  All Rights Reserved.